Jesus and Evolution
Hello from Creationfest 2010 in the UK! These are the notes from a seminar I gave entitled “Jesus and evolution” -
Jesus and Evolution
First of all, in terms of creation, you basically have only one of two choices when it comes to explaining it - it was the product of a creator, or it was the product of unguided processes (abiogenesis and evolution).
When it comes to the bible’s take on creation, it firmly and repeatedly asserts that Jesus was the Creator of the universe and everything in it.
John 1:3 - All things were made through Him, and without Him nothing was made that was made.
1 Cor. 8:6 - yet for us there is one God, the Father, of whom are all things, and we for Him; and one Lord Jesus Christ, through whom are all things, and through whom we live.
Eph. 3:9 - and to make all see what is the fellowship of the mystery, which from the beginning of the ages has been hidden in God who created all things through Jesus Christ.
Col. 1:16 - For by Him all things were created that are in heaven and that are on earth, visible and invisible, whether thrones or dominions or principalities or powers. All things were created through Him and for Him.
Heb. 1:1-2 - God, who at various times and in various ways spoke in time past to the fathers by the prophets, has in these last days spoken to us by His Son, whom He has appointed heir of all things, through whom also He made the worlds
What is creationism?
6 main views of creationism -
1) young earth creation - day = “yom” - 24 hour day = God created in 7 literal days so the earth is young but has an appearance of maturity (flood “aged” the planet) :)
2) historical creation - “in the beginning” = “rasheed” - an indefinite amount of time. The earth is old, then God created in 6 literal days. :)
3) gap theory - A creation theory that suggests there is a very long time gap between Gen. 1:2 and Gen. 1:3. During this gap, the earth became formless and void, and then God took another crack at the whole creation thing. :(
4) literary framework - the Genesis story is poetic only, and therefore gives us no real information about creation. :(
5) progressive creation (day age) - 1 day = 1000 years or more and God ‘pops’ in and out to create new things - but in Ex. 20:11 - it is clear a day is a day. :(
Ex. 20:11 - For in six days the LORD made the heavens and the earth, the sea, and all that is in them, and rested the seventh day. Therefore the LORD blessed the Sabbath day and hallowed it.
6) theistic evolution - a creation theory that suggests God started the big bang and then used the process of evolution to eventually “lead up” to human beings (aka Adam) - biblically problematic on many fronts, but mainly since the bible states we were created “in the image of God”. :(
As an aside, although 1 and 2 are the most biblical viewpoints, if age was technically that important, the bible would of clearly told us exactly how old the earth is - but it didn’t.
The most important thing to realize is that God did it - creation points to a Creator, and that Creator is Jesus.
If you don’t believe Jesus or at least a Creator did it, you are left with nothing doing it - literally. This “science” is known as abiogenesis.
What is abiogenesis? a = no; bio = life; genesis = beginning The study of how life might have originated from inanimate (non-life) forms.
What is evolution?
6 main definitions of evolution -
1) Change over time; history of nature; any sequence of events in nature. :)
2) Changes in the frequencies of alleles in the gene pool of a population. :)
3) Limited common descent: the idea that particular groups of organisms have descended from a common ancestor (aka the biblical “kind”). :)
4) The mechanisms responsible for the change required to produce limited descent with modification (aka adaptation); chiefly natural selection acting on random variations or mutations. :)
5) Universal common descent: the idea that all organisms have descended from a single common ancestor. :(
6) Blind watchmaker thesis: the idea that all organisms have descended from common ancestors through unguided, unintelligent, purposeless, material processes such as natural selection acting on random variations or mutations; the idea that the Darwinian mechanism of natural selection
acting on random variation, and other similarly naturalistic mechanisms,completely suffice to explain the origin of novel biological forms and the appearance of design in complex organisms. :(
Definitions 1 - 4 do not conflict with biblical theology
Definitions 5 and 6 do conflict with biblical theology. They also are causing much dissention with a growing number of scientists and professors - See www.discovery.org
for a list of over 800 science professionals who collectively state:
“We are skeptical of claims for the ability of random mutation and natural selection to account for the complexity of life. Careful examination of the evidence for Darwinian theory should be encouraged.”
Let’s consider some of the issues and implications associated with definitions 5 and 6:
1. Common Sense
Isaiah 1:18 - “Come now, and let us reason together…”
Again, although the origin of life is technically not evolution, if your goal is to explore the history of life on the planet, you have to study its origin eventually (abiogenesis). Once you arrive, will nothing really be able to produce something? Do we ever assume this with anything we see presently?
Can, “…undifferentiated matter, at some point, become ‘alive’, then conscious, the conceptually proficient, then an ‘I’” ?
(Anthony Flew).
2. Fearfully and Wonderfully Made
Psalm 139:14 - “I praise you for I am fearfully and wonderfully made…”
A. Amino acid specificity
Since all living things are composed of cells, and all cells are composed primarily of proteins, and all proteins are composed of amino acids (AAs) - when you consider how life developed or began, you have to take how AAs might have formed at some point.
A man named Stanley Miller tried this in 1953 - He assembled a closed system into which he pumped a mixture of gases (methane, ammonia and hydrogen). He subjected this mixture to high voltage electrodes and then cooled and trapped any liquids that were produced. What did he produce?
He produced a “soup” that contained around 9 amino acids, 2% of the simplest (glycine and alanine) and traces of 7 others. It was a great experiment, but…
1. This was done in an environment void of oxygen and nitrogen.
2. The AAs were right handed.
3. Miller had to rescue the AAs and cool them or else they would denature.
4. The yield was small.
5. He was the “creator”/designer!
So, it was a good experiment, but did not prove how AAs could form naturally - this is a complicated task with many hurdles!
For example, say you likened amino acids (there are 20 AA’s total) to the alphabet (26 letters total) - and you wanted to take those alphabetical letters and randomly drop them onto the floor until they spelled, “I love Jesus, He rocks”. To figure out the chances of this happening, you would take:
1/26 (letters in the alphabet) to the 17th power (letters in the sentence) = 1 chance in 1 million, 113 trillion octillion!
Since the smallest functional proteins are made up of at least 100 AA’s (compared to the 17 letters in our hypothetical sentence), we do the following:
1/20 (20 known amino acids) to the 100th power (simplest functional protein) - and that result would need to actually be taken to the 400th power b/c the simplest cells are composed of around 400 proteins = 1 chance in 20 to the 40000th power!
And, just so you know, it is estimated that all the grains of sand on the earth’s seashores are only 10 to the 25 power.
On top of this mathematical dilemma, remember, AA’s denature easily in the wrong environment - not a good characteristic to have if you are trying to form simply by chance in the earth’s supposedly volatile, primal oceans.
B. Genomes and Phenomes
Your body’s 100 trillion protein based cells each have a nucleus containing chromosomes which “hold” your genes in DNA. In this DNA double helix lay a spiral of nucleotides (adenine, guanine, cytosine, thymine) that make up your 3.4 billion base paired genome (your genes) - it’s basically your genetic blueprint!
Genes are segments of DNA that code for proteins.
They are like “words” in an instruction manual for building a human.
Chromosomes are like the pages in the instruction manual.
Each “page” contains thousands of “words” (genes) - different types of genes are used to make different types of: cells -> proteins -> tissues -> organs -> systems -> organisms
So your genes are in DNA which are in chromosomes, which are in nuclei, which are in every cell in your body.
Basically, the mother has 23 pages of information in her egg, and the father has 23 pages of information in his sperm - combined, this forms a new human with 46 total pages of information!
As the baby (or anything) grows, this information gets translated from DNA into amino acids which form specific proteins, which form specific cells, which form specific tissues, which form specific organs, which form specific systems, which form specific people!
This same basic format occurs in all living things - DNA gets transcribed and translated into proteins which form cells which are the building blocks of life.
$$$ MILLION DOLLAR QUESTION $$$
When it comes to DNA, how could something evolve to hold information with no initial information to tell it to hold something?
Francis Crick, co-discoverer of DNA, proposed (in a book called Life Itself) that some form of primordial life was shipped to the earth billions of years ago in spaceships—by supposedly ‘more evolved’ (therefore advanced) alien beings -
The very brilliant but very athiestic Richard Dawkins seconded this notion in an interview on the documentary “Expelled” -
So apparently creation points to E.T., Star Trek, and Alien vs Predator, not a Creator.
And, last time I checked, science needs to be testable - how does one test for aliens and signs of alien creation?
3. On a theological/philosophical note…
Since we are created in the image of God (Imago Dei), we have 5 key traits in common with Him that evolution cannot explain:
1. Spiritual - if, as some have said, religious ideas were a product of evolution, wouldn’t religion be counterproductive to evolution? This seminar should have been “selected against” :)! Also, do we know of any animals who worship? How can evolution explain this?
2. Moral - How can evolution explain morality? We do not see morality in the animal kingdom, especially the good (social justice) and bad (genocide) extremes of it. We see “kindness” within pods or packs, but a lion isn’t going to help a cheetah who is starving!
“Two things awe me most, the starry sky above me and the moral law within me.” - Immanuel Kant (German Philosopher)
3. Intellectual - Why do we question where we are from, why we are here, or where we are headed? Why do we write poetry, sing songs for no real purpose, create art, and try to understand the universe? No other creatures do this and again, evolution cannot explain this.
4. Volitional - Free will has been a human characteristic since the Garden of Eden. We are not driven by instinct, sex, or hunger, but can make decisions that are either harmful or beneficial to ourselves. Are there animal addicts or animal hunger strikes? Although we often choose poorly, we have the capacity to make wise choices (dieting, celibacy, etc). How could evolution account for this?
5. Relational - Since God Himself exists in a “community” of sorts (Trinity) - we are also social beings who are created to be in a relationship with God and with people. We share the gospel with others in this way - no other creatures proselytize other creatures into being what they are b/c they feel it’s beneficial. Humans are unique!
What are the implications of this?
Why does this even matter?
Based on material evolution, you are a completely purposeless accident based on random mutation and natural selection - you are no better than any other living creature (the only real law is survival), and the only guarantee you get is that one day you will die and become fertilizer. It stops there.
Based on biblical creation, you are not only the amazing product of an omnipotent and omniscient Designer (answers, “where am I from”?), but you also have the answers to the other 2 big questions - Why am I here? You are here (creation) because God loves you (adoration) and in through this love, became a man (incarnation), to redeem you from sin (redemption), clear your guilt (propitiation), give you His glory and holiness (imputation), thereby making peace between you and God (reconciliation) so that you can now have a relationship with Him, and be used by him to love and reach others. You have a purpose!
And…
His resurrection not only verified that all of this was accomplished, but also answers the 3rd question - where am I headed?
“In my Father’s house are many mansions: if it were not so, I would have told you. I go to prepare a place for you. And if I go and prepare a place for you, I will come again, and receive you unto myself; that where I am, there ye may be also” (John 14:2-3).
“God shall wipe away all tears from their eyes; and there shall be no more death, neither sorrow, nor crying, neither shall there be any more pain: for the former things are passed away” (Revelation 21:4).
So, with biblical creation, you not only have an explanation of origin and development - but you also know that you are loved, that you have a purpose, and that you have a hope.
With macro-evolution, you have nothing more than a theory in crisis largely driven by the loud voice of atheism with - no hope, no purpose, and no present tense and future tense answers.
Which do you choose?